Daily Kitten Chat Forum » Cats & Kittens

Two Brothers...What to Do

(11 posts)
  • Started 1 year ago by cter83
  • Latest reply from MadcatwomanintheUK
  1. Almost two months ago, our cat Dasher had to be put to sleep, after suffering paralysisdue to throwing a blood clot...he had Cardiomyopathy, so we valued everyday that we had with him. He was an amazing cat, and we absolutely loved him. I got him about 8 years go, a year before I left for college. Since I obviously could not bring him to college with me, it was an extra "connection" my mom and I had while I was away at school. My mom and I are very close, and even though she still had my dad while I was away, it was very comforting to konw that she had "my cat" home with her...and, in turn, it was very comforting to her to know she had my cat home with her as well. She would often call me to have him "meow" into the phone, or have me say goodnight to him... Plus, my cat was something I especially looked forward to coming home to. I moved back home after college, and subsequently deepened the bond between my mom and I, and "our" cat. I am now in my third year of law school, so my parents were aware that in about a year after graduation, my boyfriend I would soon be getting our own place.

    A tough move for all, I told my mom that due to my cat's health conditions, and his strong, strong dislike for new environments, that I was going to leave him home with her. It also again provided comfort for both of us, knowing that "our" cat was with my mom, and her feeling like a part of me was still living home with her. That is what made my cat's passing that much more difficult. Not only did I love him incredibly, but he was a special bond between my mom and I.

    After he passed, my mom and I knew we had to get another kitten. However, knowing that I was going to be leaving - I wanted to get HER a kitten. Therefore, since she had always wanted a Maine Coon, and since we wanted a rescue, I called over 200 rescues, consulted Petfinder, and various other adoption websites. After weeks of searching, I found a lady with a litter of Maine Coon mixes. I went up to see them when they were still seven weeks, and went back a week later again, and one of them just picked me out: McGee. I brought him home, and his amazing personality and temperment quickly made us all love him! He is just a beautiful, wonderful, perfect kitten. Though intended for my mom, I quickly found myself referring to myself as his "mom," and her as "grandma." She loved this, however, and stated the obvious, "You aren't going to give him up, huh?" We laughed, and we both decided we'd just have to get another kitten! So, we went back to the same lady, and adopted one of McGee's brothers (the adorable runt of the litter): Murphy!

    Well, soon after this, my boyfriend and I (after discussions for months), found an apartment that we knew we would like to move into. He recently accepted a position at my parents' CPA firm about an hour away, and therefore, the commute was proving difficult. So, now, I want to take McGee with me, but I am so nervous about separating the two. They are truly best of friends! They play, play fight, and cuddle all day long. They are constantly together, and do everything together. However, they are also both VERY, VERY loving with all of us individually as well!

    There are a few options, but I am not sure what is best for them. We could just keep the kittens at our respective homes: McGee with me, Murphy with my mom. Then, since I am a student and have a flexible schedule, on days when I must drive back down here for school, I could drop off my kitten at my mom's to be with Murphy during the day, and on my days off, my mom could bring Murphy up to my apartment to be with McGee. This would mean only 1-2 days a week separated. Another option would be Mon - Thurs McGee could stay here with my mom and Murphy, and then I could take both cats weekends... and lastly, I could just keep McGee at my house, and Murphy stay here, and they just visit each other occassionally. I am just not sure what the best option for them is. I am sure there is a need for consistency, however, since they are so young (and both will remain indoor cats), I think maybe it could become the "norm" for them. I also do feel it is important that the two of them see each other, since they are so close.

    Any insight, thoughts, advice would be much appreciated!

    Posted 1 year ago by cter83 #

  2. First C83 let me welcome you to TDK!!! Sounds like your entire family is wonderful and loving people. If you want my thoughts..let mom keep McGee and Murphy together..Especially right now there are so many animals that need homes you and your boyfriend might consider another Brother/Brother or Brother/Sister or Sister/Sister adoption. That way 4 furr babies can have loving forever homes..., But that's just me, I'd take in every homeless animal if I could.

    Posted 1 year ago by 2bpurring #

  3. Welcome C83! I have had many cats, and I agree, if they're very attached, keep them together. I have traveled everywhere with mine. Some were good car riders, others needed a carrier. But all, since I took them everywhere since they were young, enjoyed a good adventure, and actually like the trips. My current velcroe child (Abbi - my meeze) is so attached to me that she literally wants to be whereever I am. Right now, our living situation is somewhat unique - we are living between two commercial/residential properties, where we sleep in one and have a kitchen & bath in the other. Since my kitties are inside only, I must carry Abby with me to go from one house to the other. She is as good as gold - She rides in my arms, with her paws over my shoulder, and we walk the 20 or so fee across to the other home. It has become so much of a routine for her, that now everyday around 4-5pm, she goes to the door and starts meowing! She knows it's almost time to go over to the cooking house!

    Posted 1 year ago by AV #

  4. I just want to say welcome to TDK, CTER83.

    Posted 1 year ago by Cats4Cats #

  5. Welcome CTER83, I cast my paw for them staying together too! Then you could get two more. I will never ever have just 'one' cat again. It isn't fair to them especially when they are indoor and if you have to leave them for a while each day. Good Luck!! Enjoy TDK!!

    Posted 1 year ago by SammyandOliversmama #

  6. Welcome to TDK, CT. And I am sorry for the loss of Dasher.
    I have to agree, two is better than one. And you can never have too many (although I think my eight may be a little much). And one of mine is a Dasher, too. As a matter of fact, he is curled up on my lap as I type. LOL
    BTW: You are very lucky to have such a loving family.
    Again, welcome.

    Posted 1 year ago by artistabobbi TX 1/17 #

  7. I appreciate you all responding so quickly! :) And, while I do agree (and think I know deep down that they should stay together), I have a hard time really letting it happen when I've become so attached to both of them! I would love to have Mcgee with me, but again, I know i can't be selfish... that is why I was hoping one of the alternatives would work...

    Posted 1 year ago by cter83 #

  8. C83, I believe that kitties should know where their home is..moving them constantly might be very hard on them. Boy kitties need "Their" Domain!! and I bet you if you adopted another pair you would quickly fall in love with them.

    Posted 1 year ago by 2bpurring #

  9. 2BP, you're absolutely right.

    Posted 1 year ago by Emma #

  10. I think 2B and Emma are right. I think the cats would prefer to live in one place together. You can look forward to seeing them when you visit your Mom and you can adopt a pair and give them an awesome loving home. And Welcome to TDK! Please keep us updated on Murphy and McGee.

    Posted 1 year ago by krazikat #

  11. Hi C83, welcome to TDK! I would also be inclined to keep the two boys together, but can appreciate how this could pull at your heartstrings. But think - if you see you Mum regularly, then you'd see McGee regularly AND get to have your own cat(s) wherever you settle - sounds like the best of both worlds to me!!

    Posted 1 year ago by MadcatwomanintheUK #


RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.