Daily Kitten Chat Forum » General Chat

"In Defense of Star Trek"

(27 posts)

Tags:

  1. The reason for my writing this is explained in the first two paragraphs. The reason for posting it is that cat people, being the most sane and sensible people anywhere, are also often Star Trek fans.
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------
    IN DEFENSE OF STAR TREK
    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Dear Teacher:
    This letter is both a letter and my submission for Lesson Four. I am going to discuss a subject near and dear to my heart. I am rising "In Defense of Star Trek".
    You brought this on by suggesting, in the interest of brevity, my paragraph referring to Star Trek in my last lesson might be eliminated. I think not, for various reasons, which I shall expound upon here.
    First, a personal reaction of mine. You should know that I read a lot, and when the book I am reading makes even a passing reference to Star Trek, I immediately feel that the author and I have something in common, (and you'd be surprised how often that occasion arises), and that our outlook on the world would be simpatico. Over the years, I've had the opportunity to interact with a number of people, and when and if the subject of Star Trek comes up, I find three possible reactions; they like/love it, they hate it, or they just don't get it. It's only those people with whom a reference to Star Trek is readily appreciated that I find I am apt to form a lasting friendship. Just so with my readers. (I would here except the term "warp speed", as having become a household word. I have encountered it in the paper, on television, (by Peter Jennings, may he rest in peace), and my computer has a screen saver, 'Flying Through Space', whose warp speed is mine to command.
    The History Channel, from time to time, shows a program titled 'How William Shatner Changed the World'. FYI, William Shatner played the part of Captain Kirk in Star Trek, The Original Series. It was not so much Mr. Shatner himself, although he played an engaging character, as the ideas the program offered for contemplation that had such a profound influence on today's society. The first interracial kiss on television was aired in a Star Trek episode, and the fact that a black woman played the part of a respected officer of Star Fleet, instead of a maid, was an inspiration to African-American wannabe actors. Whoopi Goldberg grabbed it and ran with it, and look at her now.
    There was a fairly serious study made a few years ago, about which science fiction efforts, movies and television, were the "best', "most influential", had the most lasting effect on society. The two top contenders were Star Wars and Star Trek. They concluded that Star Wars was the most influential, and in terms of number of people, they may be right. The Star Wars movies are fun, and George Lucas has created a wonderful modern mythology, combining the archetypes one can find in Joseph Campbell with that other myth,"The Wizard Of Oz". What's not to like?
    But if you go to Cal Tech, JPL, NASA, you'll find more people saying 'Live long and prosper.'(Vulcan), than 'May the Force be with you.'(Jedi). Gene Roddenberry, who was the guiding genius behind Star Trek, as George Lucas was for Star Wars, was an idealist. In the three hundred or so years in the future, Roddenberry's Earth has solved the problems that plague us today. Earth is a paradise. The troubles I envisioned with my Genie, (another story-KPMom), were apparently handled somehow, although Roddenberry never offers any solutions, just results. The youngsters who view the Star Wars movies may cheer for their heroes, and yearn for Princess Leia, but the Star Trek viewers go home figuring out ways to make it come true. They build rockets and go to the moon. Our modern cell phones are more versatile than Captain Kirk's communicator. Our computers are getting there; robots and androids are front and center in Japanese technology. Much of our modern world is catching up to Star Trek as fast as it can.
    My son in Los Angeles had a t-shirt, (note past tense; I had to wrest it away from him). It said in the front of it 'RESISTANCE IS FUTILE'. Below that was a picture of a Borg. Below that it said 'YOU WILL BE ASSIMILATED'
    A Borg is a member of a collective that, in the Star Trek canon, is attempting to conquer the Galaxy. The face of the Borg was that of Bill Gates. I alnost fell off my chair laughing when I saw it, and if my son weren't the generous soul he is, I would never have gotten that shirt away from him. If those that I meet while wearing it do not react appropriately, I know a lot about them, and their state of mind, immediately. If they are seniors like me I don't take it too much to heart. I know some wonderful seniors who will never leave the 20th century, but I don't discuss computers with them any more than I discuss evolution with my evangelicsal friends.
    I think one can look at Star Trek as a password to the mind set of society. If one is passed, he is looking to the future, and he's part of the solution; if not, he's part of the problem. (Nobody but a real old-timer could have written that last sentence.)
    In general, the Star Trek episodes were fairly cerebral, even the funny ones, and it wasn't until after the death of Roddenberry that they devolved into the thud and blunder with which they ended. I think we Trekkers all had withdrawal symptoms when the last show aired. I know I did. But if anything makes me a little more hopeful about the future of mankind, it's the fact that there are people who are willing to pursue Roddenberry's vision of the future.

    May you, Teacher, live long and prosper. KPMom.

    Posted 2 years ago by KPMom #

  2. Good defense. My favorite is the IDIC (Infinite Diversity in Infinite Combinations) but I definitely relate to the Borg Tshirt.

    Posted 2 years ago by ailuromaniac #

  3. Hey KPMOM,I was wondering about the screensaver you mentioned . What is it called and where might someone look for it ? I kind of cllect them and don't think I have heard of that one . I do have one of Vorager being attacked by the Borg though.

    Posted 2 years ago by Renee in Arkansas #

  4. I am not a huge Star Trek fan, but my husband is a very big fan. Was there a misunderstanding with the assignment, is that why the comment for brevity? Sometimes a teacher is looking for something specific, and that maybe why the teacher wanted the paper shorter--not that the teacher is opposed to Star Trek.

    Posted 2 years ago by SoxsMom #

  5. Renee, I posted an answer to your question about that screen saver 'Flying Through Space', but it seems to have got lost somehow, so here we go again. It was in my computer when I bought it. Not in the list of regular choices for screen savers, but in a little inconspicuous program I stumbled across somehow. I typed its name into my regular list of choices, and voila! there it was, with all my options for warp speed, etc. I'm not very computer literate, so sometimes I go around opening programs just to see what's there. Sometimes I get a warning not to tamper with a program, so of course I don't. Sometimes I get a program I can't understand, and I leave that alone. But occasionally I find a winner, and FYS was one of them. I hope that helps, even if I can't see how.
    SOXSMOM- I don't think my teacher had any particular objective in mind when she suggested leaving out the Star Trek reference. She was just one of those people who "just didn't get it'. The comment turned me into a teacher, and my Teacher took it with very good grace, and I think she got a little more appreciation for that kind of connection. A good many of the books that I read that were written in the Star Trek era, have a passing reference to it, of any old kind. My reference to ST was in my story about a Genie, called 'A Thought Experiment", and wasn't crucial to the story, but was illuminating. I guess, since she didn't have the background, it didn't light up for her.
    I guess I'm preaching to the choir here, but I love to hear from you. Keep it up. KPMom.

    Posted 2 years ago by KPMom #

  6. Thank you so much....I love Star Trek!!!

    Posted 2 years ago by 2bpurring #

  7. Yeah, I am a fan of the original Star Trek too! Thanks for posting this, KPM

    Posted 2 years ago by JoanfromNewJersey #

  8. Big ST fan here (raises hand) :-)

    Posted 2 years ago by Siobhan #

  9. "Beam Me Up Scotty, There's No Intelligent Life Down Here!"

    On a more serious note: I'm also a very big ST fan.

    Posted 2 years ago by feral #

  10. Love ST old, medium and new. Glad you re-butted.

    Posted 2 years ago by KYKAT 12 23 #

  11. I share the same birthday as William Shatner. Also, I think I once heard James Kirk's birthday referenced as the same. Sooo, that makes Mr. Shatner a few decades older than I and Captain Kirk a few hundred years younger!

    Posted 2 years ago by JoanfromNewJersey #

  12. I've been a Trekkie since day one. Heck, I even dressed my son up as Spock for his second Halloween:

    http://c1.ac-images.myspacecdn.com/images02/11/l_e01691868093448e9f4720c5a210aa70.jpg

    He's so awesome.

    Posted 2 years ago by MouchoisMelvin #

  13. MM I love the pic of your son!!! I too have been a fan since day one...Did you see the newest ST movie???

    Posted 2 years ago by 2bpurring #

  14. When Jimmy Doohan was scheduled to appear at a convention, he would show up a day of two ahead of time so fans could have some one on one time talking to him without ten thousand people crowding around.
    DH and I met at a Star Trek convention. We were both dressed as Klingons at the time. The fan club I was in did charity events, like Big Brothers/Big Sisters and our local public television fund raiser, dressed as Klingons. It was about a year until I found out what he actually looked like.

    Posted 2 years ago by ClaudesMommy #

  15. We are definitely Trekkers in our house as well. My favorite Capt. along the voyage was Capt. Picard...and all his crew as well! I believe true Star Trek fans are a trustworthy, loyal type of people. Look at us!!! Thank you for sharing your defense of Star Trek KPMOM. =)

    Posted 2 years ago by Karenopa #

  16. Reminds me of a Sybil Shepard commercial of some years ago, for somebody's hamburgers. She said, "I don't really TRUST someone who doesn't like hamburgers."
    My version, "I don't really trust someone who doesn't like cats!" KPMom.

    Posted 2 years ago by KPMom #

  17. Good rule to live by KP. Also never date anyone that your cats don't like! 22 years ago I started dating a man and told him not only, "Love me, love my cat, but also the cat comes first. She has seniority!) He was ok with that so two years later, I married him! We will celebrate our 20th anniversary in September. When that original cat crossed the bridge and we got the current crop he had to let them know that he now has seniority! He frequently has to remind Gracie that he outranks her! She tends to disagree.

    Posted 2 years ago by KYKAT 12 23 #

  18. KYKAT, Gracie is not disagreeing, she is correcting his misconception.

    Posted 2 years ago by ailuromaniac #

  19. ... my brother and I (he's only 1 yr younger) grew up watching the original series!.....

    ...... when I'm on the golf course now, with my girl friends that are from my same "era".... and we miss a shot... we say "damn it Jim"..... then giggles persue!.....

    Posted 2 years ago by AV #

  20. "Do not meddle in the affairs of cats, for they are subtle and will piss on your computer." Bruce Graham
    You have been warned, KYKAT. I am proud to say Mycat has not pissed on my computer; she just clamps my finger on the mouse with her sturdy paw until I pay her with my attention.
    ------------------------
    Aren't we lucky? KPMom.

    Posted 2 years ago by KPMom #

  21. I know what you mean ,Cindy said that I was the first guy that her old tom cat
    approved of ,nuff said .We both watched any and all Star Trek shows that we could,you might say that our relationship was in the stars.

    Posted 2 years ago by Renee in Arkansas #

  22. Awwww....how sweet & romantic Ron!

    Posted 2 years ago by feral #

  23. Yes she must have seen something no one else did because before her I nevered dated anyone longer that 2-3 months.

    Posted 2 years ago by Renee in Arkansas #

  24. Ahhh, I'm liking this thread! Star Trek, cats and romance, awesome combination! Ron, my hubby had to take the "does-my-cat-like-you?" test too!

    Posted 2 years ago by JoanfromNewJersey #

  25. If somebody doesn't get Star Trek, there's just nothing you can do for them. The End.

    Posted 2 years ago by lisaeylau #

  26. I once met a woman who was a Star Trek fan, but who believed two mutually impossible things. Like the Red Queen. I had a number of conversations with her, but nothing I ever said penetrated her mind-set. Until I met her I would not have thought it possible to so ignore reality and still be a Star Trek fan. Don't worry, Trekkers, I'm sure she was the rarest of the rare. But now I know that it can happen, so I am a little tiny bit more cautious when I meet a fellow Trekker.
    I gave up on her, but I grieve for her. I would have thought a good dose of Star Trek would vaccinate you against total illogicality, but I guess for once it failed. (I'm sure there are many non-Trekkers who could use a good dose.)
    Cat-lovers have to be realists, otherwise their households would fall apart, and kitty might seek a home elsewhere. Double dose of healthy interests. KPMom.

    Posted 2 years ago by KPMom #

  27. Mom
    Since so many of the TDK family are apparently Star Trek fans, maybe we could start a Star Trek Quiz, like the one I made up and sent to you. Top winners would become designated as Commanders and science officers on the Enterprise or could become Vulcans if they preferred. Those doing somewhat less well could be Kingons, those doing terribly could become Romulans and those cheating could become Ferengis.

    Posted 2 years ago by kitty poet #


RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.